Chester Managers – FA Cup Record

Having reached the FA Cup 1st Round, and facing Football League opposition for the first time since 2014/15, I thought it would be interesting to look at the FA Cup statistics for Chester managers over the years.

It is obviously difficult to make a direct comparison between the pre- 2010 Chester and reformed Chester FC that has only entered the competition at the Qualifying Round stages but it is still interesting to see that Calum McIntyre has now managed the club in 18 FA Cup ties prior to the Cambridge United game. This puts him 4th behind Frank Brown, Ken Roberts and Harry McNally while his win record puts him level with Alan Oakes and one behind Frank Brown.

Prior to 1930 the team was picked by committee so Frank Brown and Harry McNally hold the record for most FA Cup ties managed in a season. During the 1938/39 campaign Chester played seven ties under Brown beating Second Division Coventry City on the way and taking Second Division Sheffield Wednesday to a second replay in the 4th Round. Harry McNally also managed the club in seven ties, during 1986/87, including three games against Rotherham United before coincidentally being eliminated by Sheffield Wednesday in a 4th Round replay.

Alan Oakes has arguably the most impressive FA Cup record with 10 victories in his 17 games in charge. This includes taking Chester to the last 16 on two occasions, in 1976/77 and 1979/80. Both these campaigns featured victories over teams in a higher division, Luton Town in 1976/77 and Newcastle United in 1979/80. Since reforming in 2010 the only times Chester have beaten teams from a higher division has been under Steve Burr (Southend United 2014/15) and Calum McIntyre (Hartlepool United 23/24 and Morecambe 25/26).

Only three managers have achieved victories over clubs two divisions higher. In 1969/70 Fourth Division Chester beat Second Division Bristol City 2-1 under Ken Roberts. In 2000/01 Graham Barrow’s Conference side beat third tier Oxford United 3-2 while two seasons later Mark Wright’s Blues beat another third tier team, Colchester United at Layer Road. This remains the only occasion that Chester have beaten a team two divisions higher away from home so Calum has the chance of equalling this record at Cambridge.

The worst FA Cup record belongs to Louis Page who managed the club in three ties over three seasons in the mid 1950s and lost them all.

ManagerFirst FA Cup SeasonLast FA Cup SeasonPlayedWonDrawnLostFurthest Round
CHESTER/CHESTER CITY
Charlie Hewitt1930/311935/36168264Rr
Alex Raisbeck1936/371937/3831024R
Frank Brown1938/391952/532411584Rr2
Louis Page1953/541955/5630031R
John Harris1956/571958/5982332Rr
Stan Pearson1959/601961/6252032R 
Bill Lambton1962/631962/6310011R
Peter Hauser1963/641967/68116053R
Ken Roberts1968/691975/76249784R
Alan Oakes1976/771981/821710165R
John Sainty1982/831982/8320111Rr
Trevor Storton1983/841983/8410011R
John McGrath1984/851984/8510011R
Harry McNally1985/861991/92218674Rr
Graham Barrow1992/931993/9462223R
Mike Pejic1994/951994/9521012R 
Kevin Ratcliffe1995/961998/9973043R
Terry Smith1999/20001999/200042113R
Graham Barrow2000/012000/0153113R
Steve Mungall2001/022001/0210014Q
Mark Wright2002/032003/0453022R 
Ian Rush2004/052004/0532013R
Keith Curle2005/062005/0642113Rr
Mark Wright2006/072006/0751223Rr *
Bobby Williamson2007/082007/0810011R
Simon Davies2008/092008/0910011R
Jim Harvey2009/102009/1020114Qr
TOTAL183763374
* – Chester lost to Bury in the 2nd Round but were reinstated after Bury played an ineligible player
CHESTER FC
Neil Young2012/132013/1451224Q
Steve Burr2014/152015/1652122Rr
Jon McCarthy2016/172016/1710014Q
Marcus Bignot2017/182017/1810014Q
Anthony Johnson and Bernard Morley2018/192021/22114344Q
Calum McIntyre2022/231810441Rr
TOTAL41171014

Jimmy Rolfe (1932-2025)

Former Chester winger Jimmy Rolfe has passed away at the age of 93. Jimmy made 50 Division Three North appearances for the club between 1953 and 1955 and also played in the Football League for Crewe Alexandra and Barrow.

Jimmy Rolfe

Jimmy started his football career at Eastham Athletic where his performances attracted the attention of Liverpool who signed him on amateur terms. Over the next two years he featured in both the A and B teams before being called up for National Service. While serving in Germany he represented the Combined Services and also played for Munster 08. After being demobbed, in July 1952, Jimmy returned to Anfield and signed as a professional before being released in summer 1953.

Debut v Workington in September 1953

The Liverpool born player became one of Louis Page’s first signings for Chester and he made his Football League debut in a 3-0 win over Workington at Sealand Road in September 1953. After playing in the following game at Darlington Jimmy returned to the reserves but nine goals in five games, including hat-tricks in consecutive games against Northwich Victoria and Mossley, saw him return to first team action in a side desperate for goals. Unfortunately Jimmy couldn’t translate his goalscoring form for the reserves to the first team and by February he was back in the Cheshire County League team before being reinstated at the end of the campaign when he won a Welsh Cup runners up medal after featuring in the final against Flint Town United.

Jimmy Rolfe returns to the team against Rochdale

The following season Jimmy featured 33 times on the right wing, adding one goal to his previous season’s tally of three, before surprisingly being given a free transfer in 1955. Standing at just over 5ft 6ins he made up for his lack of height with energy and enthusiasm but was probably unlucky to feature in a struggling team that finished bottom of the table in both 1953/54 and 1954/55.

Jimmy Rolfe in rightmost pale top 1954

After departing Sealand Road Jimmy went on to play more than 100 games for Crewe followed by Barrow and then had a very brief spell at Southport. Dropping into non-league football, in 1959, he featured for Runcorn, Buxton, Holyhead and New Brighton. After leaving the game he worked for Littlewoods.